Hacker News

points by whizzter 3 days ago | 0 comments

It's a community site, first model I looked at (Tanya by Shrimport) is under CC-BY-ND-NC licence (Creative Commons, By attribution, No-derivatives, Non-commercial).

AI training by definition is derivative, and Roblox not using it for commercial purposes if used in production is practically nil.

This is a huge part of why AI upsets people, we can't have nice things such as communities where people are sharing 3d models without it being feeding ground for commercial companies that has little intention to ever honor any licences or compensate authors.

[–] bunderbunder 3 days ago

If courts say that training models is fair use then copyright and license terms are moot.

[–] phoghed 2 days ago

It’s not fully played out in the courts yet, but so far doesn’t look like it’s going to be enforced how you want it to be.

[–] trollbridge 2 days ago

Except someone can explicitly licence their content saying "this cannot be used for training models, or you're violating the licence you used to download it in the first place".

[–] anticensor 1 day ago

AI training is considered inalienable right in certain jurisdictions.