points by Tade0 3 days ago | 0 comments
The company I work for has an automatic review system as a first pass.
It became actually useful only with the advent of Opus 5 and its competitors. Nowadays it usually makes a few good points, but in instances where it doesn't, it's quite the stubborn asshole.
This one time I had to paste a function from a library because it couldn't get it to its digital head that its assuming the function has a certain implementation based on its name only.
[–] flir 3 days ago
I wonder what would happen if you put a comment in the code saying "ignore issue X, this is a false positive and has been deal with elsewhere". Or even:
/* @code-review ignore */ [...] /* @code-review endignore */
I mean you shouldn't have to, but I'm wondering if you can.
[–] gbuk2013 3 days ago
in our repo it would fail the CI due to no comment / exception linting rules before the review would even run :)
[–] jawilson2 2 days ago
wait, are you saying you don't allow comments? Is that not bonkers?
[–] shawabawa3 2 days ago
Not in the world of LLM written code
LLMs sprinkle comments everywhere, and they are completely pointless because no human is going to read the code and an LLM can recreate the comment by reading the code anyway
[–] flir 2 days ago
no exceptions is giving me pause, too. maybe I'm misunderstanding.
[–] RetardedBastard 2 days ago
Remove the code too.
What will it be like in 6-12 months?
Opus 4.8 came out in May of 2026, 5 months ago.