points by bemtevi 2 days ago | 0 comments
As a part-time software developer, one of the problems I think is the following: AI/LLM coding may actually be improving some software, true. But I think it's often in domains where we've already made a lot of progress, and AI helps put the finishing organizing touches on things.... but when it comes to new ideas or new software, I think AI is making things worse.
For instance: an AI-assisted developer can probably make a pretty decent basic text editor, but let's say they need to make an entirely new type of app, then I think the new app will lack polish or finesse because no one has made that before. Or AI can help find bugs in mature, well-written code but what if someone needs to write a new kind of app? Then there's a lack of polish again...
[–] LtWorf 2 days ago
[–] senfiaj 2 days ago
I guess the tendency is the problems shifting to higher levels, while for lower level or common problems things are getting more robust and better.
[–] bemtevi 2 days ago
I think that makes sense. The question is, is that a good thing? I sometimes wonder if contact with sufficiently 'lower levels' actually supports mental health in a way. Maybe not coding in 1's and 0's, maybe not even assembly, but maybe there is an optimal distance from the bare metal and we're moving farther away from that optimal...
AI companies are seemingly having a hard time to make a text editor that doesn't flicker so I think AI cannot make a simple text editor.
(Claude Code)