Hacker News
points by stldev 2 days ago | 0 comments
Can you name a single western democracy where the citizens are prohibited from criticizing their government?
[–] seanw444 2 days ago
France just banned protesting
[–] cowlevel 2 days ago
Didn't the USA also? I seen to remember that in Florida they passed a law that says you can run over protestors with your car.
[–] lp0_on_fire 2 days ago
It’s more akin to “stand your ground” laws (whether you’re for or against them). In situations where you reasonably fear for your life, like surrounded by an angry mob of people in the street busting up your car.

It’s not a blank check to run over people holding signs you don’t like as you drive home from work.

[–] blitzar 2 days ago
France just banned rioting
[–] cowlevel 1 day ago
synonym for protesting when the government doesn't like it
[–] blitzar 1 day ago
there is protesting and then there is rioting and looting - its petty criminality and nothing grand like beheading elites
[–] majorchord 2 days ago
No they didn't.

> Under French law and Article 11 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR), authorities may prohibit particular demonstrations when serious public-order risks make restrictions necessary and proportionate. They cannot impose an indiscriminate prohibition on peaceful assemblies simply because previous demonstrations have descended into violence.

[–] seanw444 2 days ago
You just described the mechanism by which they did. Sure, they didn't make it illegal nationwide permanently, because what serious country would do that and hope to maintain control? The real threat is in the vague exceptions for specific cases, which they have now used.