Hacker News
points by gpvos 17 hours ago | 0 comments
My thoughts as well. It appears that such signal failures happen so often that the controllers regularly let trains run through red under verbal authorization. I don't know the exact protocols, but I would expect a driver to ask for confirmation, as happened here, and then trust the control centre. However, there is clearly a huge systemic problem, with added complexity for the controllers, and there should at least be double checks in the control centre.
[–] 1718627440 16 hours ago
The person who controls whether the light shows red or green and gives verbal authorization is the same. It's both a tool, to transmit the same information.
[–] pixl97 9 hours ago
Same information, no.

A person saying you have a green light when you have a red light is not the same information at all. The probability that something has gone wrong and will lead to disaster is many many times higher.

[–] 1718627440 6 hours ago
That's also true, but you should also be able to trust written movement authorities, otherwise why have them in the first place?