If the common hardware customers already have fails when you attempt to use a newer codec (but works fine otherwise), that can't be said to be a mainstream codec yet.
Your particular model is not representative of "the common hardware" as a whole. And it can be mainstream even when a significant fraction of devices can't use it. AV1 is a third of Netflix streams and most YouTube streams, that's more than enough to qualify as mainstream.
Even if half the devices were broken, it would still be more than a third of streams and mainstream.
A lot less than half of devices are broken when playing YouTube, I assure you.
If they stopped forcing it, it would still be the best choice most of the time. It doesn't "have to be" forced to be a major choice. The forcing changes the exact percentage but not the overall picture.
[–] GeekyBear 10 hours ago
[–] Dylan16807 10 hours ago
[–] GeekyBear 9 hours ago
Mainstream support doesn't have to be forced.
[–] Dylan16807 8 hours ago
A lot less than half of devices are broken when playing YouTube, I assure you.
If they stopped forcing it, it would still be the best choice most of the time. It doesn't "have to be" forced to be a major choice. The forcing changes the exact percentage but not the overall picture.