Hacker News

points by bakugo 10 hours ago | 0 comments

> Does the project have an inclusive code of conduct?

If you want a project to be community driven, adding an agreement that empowers its leaders to punish and exclude any community member for any reason, including reasons that have nothing to do with the project itself, is the opposite of that.

Codes of conduct result in dictator-driven projects, not community-driven projects.

[–] ranger207 10 hours ago

A community _will_ form around any piece of software with enough users and developers, regardless of if it has a code of conduct or not. And communities will almost inevitably develop community standards and cliques. The code of conduct simply formalizes that. Someone who gets kicked out of a community with a code of conduct is equally likely to get kicked out of a community without a code of conduct

And besides that, someone can always make their own community around FOSS software. Fork and move on. But the new community will compete with the old, and it's possible that the fact that people stay with the old community means that they actually prefer that community

[–] nonethewiser 10 hours ago

And inclusive of whom?

[–] lukeify 10 hours ago

The entire post is heavily driven by this author's ideologies around what they believe to correct. I mean just look at the footer and tell me this is someone on a reasonable part of the political spectrum.

[–] crabmusket 9 hours ago

What did you find unreasonable about the footer?

[–] immibis2 10 hours ago

That's literally what a blog post is, yes.

[–] rjsw 9 hours ago

Nothing stopping you starting your own "Nazis welcome" community.

[–] lukeify 3 hours ago

You are part of the problem.