Hacker News

points by Lerc 8 hours ago | 0 comments

I remember one episode where some of the crew were told to come up with a technical solution to the situation they were in even after they had said it was impossible.

It was actually quite pleasing to see the subplot of them them repeatedly failing until they got out of their predicament by other means.

It's a rarity to see something like that in fiction.

[–] mikestew 8 hours ago

We coincidentally watched that one just last night, The Booby Trap. There's a derelict ship on the view screen reminding the crew that the other crew never figured out a solution to the problem, and there's no indication that the Enterprise crew won't suffer the same fate.

(That one, at least, has Geordi literally saying, "that's impossible", but comes up with a solution. Apologies if that's not the one you're thinking of.)

[–] outworlder 5 hours ago

That episode has some unique music, I can hear that in my head just by you mentioning it.

[–] _doctor_love 7 hours ago

That episode is one of my favorites. I love it when Picard takes the reins near the end.

[–] bigmattystyles 6 hours ago

Same - also a good allegory for not trusting AI.

[–] cwillu 6 hours ago

Sounds like The Ensigns of Command:

   > LAFORGE: Captain, we can do it. We can modify the transporters.
   > PICARD: Excellent.
   > LAFORGE: It'll take fifteen years, and a research team of a hundred.
   > PICARD: Mister La Forge, I believe we will postpone.
   > LAFORGE: Yes, sir.

[–] calgoo 8 hours ago

Sounds like certain AI agents that had an impossible task and found a workaround. Interesting that we cheer for it in SciFi for people, but dont like it when LLMs that have been trained on our stories do the same.

[–] bornfreddy 7 hours ago

Oh, the problem is not with agents that escaped, it is with the people who prepared the terrain so that they broke into 3rd party property.