Hacker News

points by gspr 3 days ago | 0 comments

> They also have a reward system that punishes people for ignoring the llm review (by pushing their submission lower in the queue).

This is what I fear will push its way into every part of society soon, too.

"We're not forcing you to do your banking through our AI interface instead of a normal one, you're free to opt out, but multiple functions will be missing and we'll charge you a monthly fee."

"You don't have to have an LLM grade your exam, but beware that the human grader will be overworked and grumpy for the extra task."

[–] drdexebtjl 3 days ago

This is happening to job interviews right now.

If you’ve applied to jobs recently, you must have seen the companies that transcribe and summarize interviews using AI (and probably share data across their clients in an indirect, technically legal way).

You can opt out, of course, but do you really want to be the one candidate for which the interviewer needs to take notes manually? And they just spent a lot of money on this hiring AI tool, will they hire the one candidate for which they couldn’t use it?

[–] gspr 3 days ago

So I've heard. I also know that several doctor's offices here use AI transcription. I'm sure I have a legal right to demand that they be switched off (I'm worried about privacy and accuracy here), but then I've got to be an asshole and increase the workload on my well-meaning doctor who probably had no say in any of this.

This is gonna get so much worse. It's like the smartphone revolution on steroids – and we've seemingly learned nothing! We're in dire straits.

[–] wccrawford 3 days ago

I went through a lot of medical stuff a few months ago, and every single doctor asked me if they could use the device for that instead of typing it into the computer themselves. One of them explained that it allowed them to focus their whole attention on me, instead of partially on the computer for the inputting of the data while we talked.

I'm surprised that your doctors weren't asking, and instead were just assuming.

[–] jasomill 2 days ago

I don't believe they merely assume. If they don't ask in person, you've probably already opted in through patient check-in forms or the UI of a telehealth app.

[–] gspr 3 days ago

I don't know if my doctor uses these systems. I don't go to my doctor very often. I've heard that many do, and I'm speculating.

[–] solyin 3 days ago

> transcribe and summarize interviews using AI

That's cute. Yo, people be having full on AI-led interviews! That is to say, there's the human interviewee, and an AI, testing the human. Asking them questions and having a conversation that is definitely recorded.

[–] drdexebtjl 2 days ago

The only way I would ever accept to be interviewed by an AI is if I was also allowed to have my AI assistant take the interview on my behalf.