Hacker News
points by nekusar 1 day ago | 0 comments
Its honestly one of the biggest problems with this site. Some large post, 400 comments in, gets flagged cause of a few snowflakes got their feelings hurt.

And instead of the article just not being shown to them, their whim is forced on everybody.

And even if it is an incendiary news article, the discussions are usually still better than average. But no, a few whinys kill it for everyone.

[–] fhdkweig 1 day ago
> gets flagged cause of a few snowflakes got their feelings hurt

correction: some guy got his wallet hurt.

It is clear to me that monied/political interests are on every platform, including this one.

[–] slowin 1 day ago
Indeed, flagging should be disabled for any post with more than like 50 upvotes.
[–] cowlevel 1 day ago
Then you'd see the opposite - you'd see brand new attack posts with 51 upvotes and no comments.
[–] slowin 1 day ago
Sounds better than flagging a post people are interested in.
[–] nekusar 1 day ago
I was looking more at quantity of posts, and not as much upvotes.

But nope, my original comment is flagged. Le sigh.

[–] slowin 1 day ago
Yes, I agree. Posts with a lot of comments should also not be flagged. Maybe that's an even better metric. I don't know why your comment was flagged, it seemed pretty reasonable to me!
[–] blooalien 1 day ago
> Posts with a lot of comments should also not be flagged.

Sometimes a lot of comments on a post are a sign that the post was extremely interesting and has generated equally interesting discussion, and sometimes it's entirely the opposite signal; said post was a "trigger" topic generating a pointless flame-war that nobody in their right mind wants to read or participate in. The numbers alone aren't the whole picture, but only a small detail that signals something is happening there. This is one of those situations where LLMs/"AI" (love/hate it) could actually be a huge help, classifying particularly "active" posts into useful "buckets" by type.

[–] slowin 1 day ago
> nobody in their right mind wants to read or participate in. T

Except for all of the people commenting and up voting! There's zero downside to turning off flags there. If you don't want to read it or participate, you don't have to.

The culture of having active discussions killed is way more frustrating and discouraging.

[–] alex1138 1 day ago
A bunch of people working in the industry with a vested interest in shaping narrative being able to flag any comment or post whenever. What could POSSIBLY go wrong